What really is a reactive dog?

Understanding mobilized sympathetic responses

In just one walk, I observed a range of sympathetic responses in my adolescent intact female, Sunny D, across different contexts: a startle reaction in an open field, anticipatory motor loading on a roadside, uncertainty in response to loud children, and controlled threshold exposure during a distant parallel pass with another dog.

On the surface, these events might all be labeled “reactivity.” However, collapsing them into a single category obscures important distinctions in nervous system function.

Sympathetic activation is not a diagnosis. It is a state of mobilization. What matters is the structure of that mobilization: its onset, posture, sequence, relational access, and recovery profile.

Let's take a look how the same dog demonstrated three distinct patterns of sympathetic engagement, each requiring a different interpretation.

Sympathetic Activation Is Mobilization, Not Meaning

The sympathetic nervous system prepares the body for action. Increased muscle tone, forward pressure, visual intensity, increased heart rate, and heightened orienting are all normal physiological shifts under arousal. The critical question is not whether a dog becomes activated, but what the activation is organizing toward.

Is it defensive startle? Is it frustrated access? Is it motor pattern loading? Is it novelty processing with intact regulation?

Without examining sequence and posture, these states are easily conflated.

Scenario One: Reflexive Startle With Intact Relational Tether

In an open field, a dog appeared suddenly at close range. The response was immediate and explosive: forward lunge and vocal burst. However, there was no sustained fixation or muscular lock, and no persistence toward the stimulus. When verbally oriented, Sunny disengaged without leash pressure and returned to proximity. The lingering issue was prolonged vigilance, not organized aggression.

This event is best understood as a startle-induced sympathetic discharge with intact relational access and incomplete recovery.

The explosion was reflexive, not structured.

Scenario Two: Proximity-Triggered Motor Loading Under Restriction

In a roadside setting, a dog approached at visible distance. Rather than a reflexive burst, my dog lowered into a compressed crouch with sustained visual fixation. She did not check back in. She remained physically restrained as the dog passed within close range. Once access was fully unavailable, she erupted into a forceful discharge.

This sequence—orient, compress, lock, proximity under restraint, thwarted access, explosion—reflects motor pattern loading under restriction. The discharge was not random hostility. It was the release of stored activation after the predatory-approach components of the motor sequence had begun organizing.

This is distinct from fear-based reactivity. It is also distinct from simple social frustration. It represents organized activation without deceleration.

Scenario Three: Novelty With Processing and Recovery

In another field context, a group of loud children startled her. She oriented forward with tension, lip licking, and low tail carriage—clear signs of uncertainty. She briefly reoriented to me, remained in proximity, and resumed sniffing as the children moved away.

This event demonstrated mild sympathetic activation with intact processing and self-regulation. Sniffing behavior indicated a return to parasympathetic engagement.

Not all forward pressure is threat. Not all tension predicts escalation.

Scenario Four: Threshold Exposure With Maintained Distance

In a final clip, she observed a group with a dog at distance. She oriented and advanced slightly. A brief verbal interruption prevented motor loading. When the dog’s tags rattled, she startled and advanced again; a second interruption halted movement. The group passed without proximity, and she returned to baseline sniffing without residual vigilance.

Here, threshold was preserved. Distance prevented compression. Recovery was immediate.

This was controlled exposure without escalation.

What These Patterns Reveal

Across contexts, several consistent themes emerge:

1. Distance is the primary regulator of intensity.

2. Restriction amplifies motor loading.

3. Once visual lock and compression begin, relational access diminishes.

4. Baseline arousal strongly influences proximity tolerance.

5. Recovery profile is more informative than initial explosion.

   
   

Importantly, not all sympathetic activation is about safety. Some is defensive startle. Some is novelty processing. Some is frustrated access. Some is organized motor pattern activation.

Treating all mobilization as fear oversimplifies the intervention. Treating all forward intensity as aggression misrepresents the underlying physiology.

The work is in reading sequence, not labeling behavior.

Prognosis and Maturity

What determines long-term outcome is not whether a dog ever mobilizes. It is whether threshold is repeatedly violated or protected.

Repeated proximity under restriction strengthens compression. Repeated exposure below threshold strengthens deceleration.

A mature dog is not one who never activates. It is one who notices, assesses, orients, and moves on without loading.

That maturation requires management, distance integrity, baseline regulation, and prevention of rehearsal—not forceful suppression of activation.

Understanding mobilized sympathetic responses allows us to differentiate:

• Reflexive discharge from organized escalation

• Frustration from predation

• Uncertainty from hostility

• Suppression from regulation

  
  

These distinctions change how we intervene.

In my upcoming Body Language Workshop, we will learn about the three states of the canine nervous system. Because knowing body language is nervous system literacy.

Once you can read mobilization accurately, you can respond proportionately. And proportional response is what builds life long stability.

Understanding mobilized sympathetic responses requires more than labeling behavior as “reactive” or “aggressive.” Nervous system literacy allows us to distinguish between startle, frustration, motor loading, uncertainty, and organized escalation. These distinctions shape how we intervene, how we manage threshold, and how we evaluate recovery. The following terms are defined both clinically and in plain language to support accurate interpretation and proportionate response.

Glossary of terms: Sympathetic Activation - your dog’s body is “gearing up” for action. It doesn’t automatically mean fear or aggression: just energy preparing to move. Threshold - the distance or intensity level where your dog stops thinking clearly and starts reacting. Baseline Arousal - how “revved up” your dog already is before anything happens. Motor Loading - the moment your dog goes very still and focused right before they explode. Visual Fixation (Visual Lock) - when your dog locks onto something and seems to tune everything else out, including you. Predatory Motor Sequence - the built-in chase sequence all dogs have even if they never intend to harm anything. Frustration (Thwarted Access) - your dog wants to get to something and can’t, and that blocked energy bursts out. Relational Tether - even when excited, your dog can still “hear” you and choose you. Deceleration - how well your dog can calm back down after getting worked up. Discharge - the explosion after holding in a lot of built-up energy. Recovery Profile - how quickly and smoothly your dog settles after something big happens.

---

Jessica Logan is a dog behavior specialist and educator based on Salt Spring Island, helping people and dogs build safety, trust, and understanding through connection and co-regulation.